Case Studies
Case Study: Influencing national social policy
|
Peter Mumford with colleague, Ray Flux, were commissioned by a consortium of the King’s Fund, the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, Help the Aged, Age Concern and seven other national charities to facilitate a series of eight national conferences. The purpose of the conferences was to gather the views of older people, policy makers and service providers on who will pay for social care for older people in the future. The aim was to raise awareness and influence national policy. EPI Associates’ contribution to the programme was to: Work from the initial ideas for the conferences, develop a robust methodology that would work well for the wide range of participants invited (policy makers, politicians, service providers and commissioners, service users and carers, members of the public) Create a participative and engaging series of conferences that would also generate a consistent and usable set of data and evidence to test out and inform complex policy proposals Design conference materials to brief participants Brief, equip and de-brief a set of facilitators for each conference |
Design, prepare, validate and administer an electronic questionnaire for use at the conferences and on the ‘Caring Choices’ web site Collate responses to questionnaires and provide analysis Review and refine conferences as the national programme progressed This proved to be very a successful programme, testing policy options with stakeholders and influencing the government to commission a green paper reviewing the future funding of social care in the UK. What our clients say…‘Your work contributed significantly to the successful outcome of the Caring Choices initiative in influencing the long term care funding reform agenda.’ ‘Consistently very high levels of satisfaction with the conferences in terms of understanding the issues, contributing to the discussions and quality of facilitation.’ |
Case Study: Improving diabetes services across an SHA
|
EPI Associates was commissioned by an SHA in the north of England to design and direct a participative conference to bring about improvements to the planning and delivery of diabetes services. A large steering group was already in place with high expectations to make a wide range of rapid and practical improvement to services. They had already decided to hold a conference when EPI Associates was approached. EPI Associates’ contribution to the programme was to: Clarify the context and aspirations for the conference with the steering group Explore possible design options for the day Refine the design and develop an extended invitation list with the client Co-design invitation and briefing materials Prepare conference materials in conjunction with the client Brief and prepare the conference venue and support team Facilitate the event Support client with follow up and action planning |
The conference involved over 100 service users and 150 service providers and planners from across the SHA. This proved to be a very successful event, generating many new initiatives, confirming commitment to others, strengthening important networks, involving users in service improvement and creating a series of common interest project groups. What our clients say…‘We await the concrete outputs which will be fascinating, but engagement (and enjoyment) were obvious from a start. I’m sure you saw my amazement that such a simple idea could produce such a brilliant and time efficient process.’ ‘Thank you for your support and excellent facilitation of the steering group and at the conference. We achieved much more than I expected from the day and it has given a fantastic boost to the whole programme.’ |
Case Study: Users involved in service improvement
|
EPI Associates was commissioned by the nursing directorate of a multi-site acute trust faced with a poorly criticised service. There was a commitment from the hospital board to significantly improve users’ experience and the quality of care received. We successfully involved over 100 service users, carers and relatives, service providers, planners and commissioners in a very productive day. A range of practical plans was generated, with a clear mandate and encouragement to persevere, changed attitudes were reported and an atmosphere created that promoted dialogue across the system and further service improvement. We achieved this by: Close partnership working with the steering group to refine the purpose of the conference in the wider service and organisational context Making the client aware of the opportunities and requirements of a whole systems approach |
Discussing and agreeing the most appropriate processes and agenda for the day Careful preparation of accessible materials to prepare participants and enable them to fully participate on the day Responsive and effective facilitation of the conference What our clients say…‘Good level of participation, people were able to express their views, good learning experience.’ ‘Sincere thanks for your excellent facilitation of the workshop and for guiding preparations, it has been a very good learning process not only for me but for everyone involved.’ ‘Directly talking to individuals with learning disabilities was fantastic – and listening to their views on the service we provide and their negative and positive experiences.’ ‘Feedback from the event has been very positive and participants have commented on your excellent facilitation skills in creating an atmosphere that enabled them to voice their views.’ |
Case Study: Contentious service reconfiguration
|
EPI Associates was commissioned to prepare, design and facilitate a workshop to tackle conflict over the location and future configuration of midwifery services serving a population of 750,000 residents. The workshop involved multiple stakeholders: users, practitioners, local councillors and Patient and Public Involvement (PPI) representatives. Feelings were running high, positions were entrenched and the debate was politically sensitive. We were able to: Get participants to step back, look at the wider picture and appreciate alternative positions to their own Gain agreement to a set of criteria on which to judge emerging proposals Generate two credible new options for future services Create an atmosphere of greater respect for other’s motives and reasoning Help individuals out from positions where they were unable to make a useful contribution |
We achieved this by: Close partnership working with the client to clarify the context and what had led up to this situation Preparatory discussions with a number of the potential participants to get to know them, explore issues and concerns from their perspective and in some cases help them clarify their views Discuss and agree with the client the most appropriate processes and agenda for the day Responsive and effective facilitation of the workshop What our clients say…‘Thank you for a very good day, we got much further then I thought we could’ ‘Very helpful to the overall reconfiguration programme, thank you, you did an excellent job.’ |
Case Study: Action planning following Health Care Commission Investigation
|
Peter Mumford and colleague, Breda Flaherty, designed an innovative stakeholder involvement programme following a highly critical HCC report on Sutton and Merton PCT’s service for people with a learning disability to create a shared action plan across staff, services users and carers to improve services following an HCC enquiry. We designed a series of linked meetings and workshops to gather contributions on what to change and how to do it. We successfully involved: People who used the service and their advocates |
More than 70 members of staff More than 20 families Strategic Health Authority, Department of Health, PCT board, Learning Disability Partnership Board, Social Services The plan was adopted by the HCC in March ’07 and is now in Year 1 implementation. Our innovative approach was officially commended by the HCC. Read more at www.healthcarecommission.org.uk |
Case Study: Coaching for a newly appointed Medical Director
|
A newly appointed medical director of a district general hospital was looking for support to make the transition to the new role. A coach from EPI Associates worked with him over 18 months on: how he could best adapt his skills and experience to work effectively in a very demanding role, make the necessary personal and professional transitions, how to approach resolving problems in new ways, and providing him with support to resolve complex and longstanding clinical problems. |
‘Looking back coaching helped me get established quickly, which was critical in this job. We have also worked on the areas of the role that I have found most stressful. Being able to talk through problems has been very helpful, I have been able to explore problems from different angles and then use relevant frameworks that help with how I might approach problems more constructively.’ |
Case Study: Coaching for a stressed Teaching Hospital Clinical Director
|
The frustration with pressure and demands on busy clinical and research workload were making life difficult for a newly appointed clinical director. EPI Associates gave him assistance in handling reputation and well established patterns of behaviour and supported him with a range of approaches to resolving conflict and influencing colleagues. |
‘It has made a huge difference: how to approach the role, fitted CD role into working life (would have driven myself mad). A lot of senior clinicians would benefit from this way of working. Very practical, the most useful thing I have done.’ |
Case Study: Coaching and career support for Operations Director
|
Having completed a senior manager leadership programme this operations director wanted to move to a more challenging role. We helped him apply what he had been learning on the leadership programme in his current role and coached him through the transition to a new post. |
‘It helped me keep up the pace after the formal programme finished.’ |
Case Study: Communications directors learning set
|
A group of busy, pressured communications directors were looking for an opportunity to network and gain access to professional development. The set met four times per year and worked on live issues, common challenges and had access to relevant professional development materials. |
‘The set has given us a unique setting for focused peer support and challenge on really pressing issues that is just not possible with colleagues in our own organisations’. ‘I look forward to these sessions; it gives me space and time to think in the company of colleagues I have come to trust’. |
Case Study: ‘Board to Board’ between Acute Trust and PCT
|
EPI Associates was commissioned by the chairman of a large acute trust to prepare, design and facilitate a ‘Board to Board’ workshop with their PCT on a series of contentious issues. Preparatory meetings were held with the Chair and Chief Executive of each board to clarify context, level of interest and potential aspirations. From this an agenda and design for the day was agreed. |
The day was successful in addressing and resolving a number of practical issues and in re-establishing a constructive dialogue and attitude between the two sets of board members and a further meeting was agreed. ‘Thank you for your careful preparation - |
Case Study: Development for a new commissioning team
|
A newly formed PCT commissioning team needed to develop a strategy and establish how to work constructively with each other. EPI Associates was approached by the commissioning director and once the initial brief was clear we suggested semi structured interviews with a cross section of the new team to get their perspective and help shape the opening workshop. The interviews helped individuals work out what issues they faced, what they needed to work on as a team and what could most usefully be addressed with the benefit of a facilitator. The day addressed the big strategic issues facing the team and looked at the personal styles and preferences of team members through the use of the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI). |
Actions concerning the strategy were agreed, and practical ways of making the most of team members’ preferences were to be tested out. ‘A worthwhile day that has helped me and the team make good progress on the big issues we face, we needed the time together off site’. |
Case Study: Mediation and support to a General Practice partnership
|
EPI Associates was approached by the senior partner of a 6 partner practice. The partnership was under pressure: Two partners were due to retire Two other partners were in serious conflict with each other Clinical service quality was generally very good The practice had a good reputation Staff morale was deteriorating Senior partner and others concerned what the future held for the practice A week end away for the partners had been booked Following an opening discussion with the senior partner, we agreed we would interview each partner, to get to know them and they us, and then feed back to the partners our initial observations and suggestions. From this we would agree the content and agenda for the week end away. |
With the use of facilitated discussions, and some introduced materials we were able to tease out with the partnership the underlying issues and put the conflict into perspective. From here, with the use of MBTI and other materials we were able to explore alternative practical approaches to managing the practice and enable the partners to make the most of their preferences, personal interests and skills. 'You have helped clear the air between us and we have now sorted practical ways to resolve our differences and use them. I feel more hopeful about our future, thank you.' |
Case Study: London teaching hospital senior clinicians' introduction to leadership programme
|
Peter Mumford and colleague, Breda Flaherty, developed this popular and successful 3 day modular programme which runs twice a year to provide leadership development to more recently appointed senior clinicians. It complements and builds on a 3 day in-house Trust induction programme. For many it is their first exposure to a leadership development programme. It has proved to be very successful for individuals who are trying to get established in their department and develop aspects of their service. |
‘As a doctor, I don’t learn this at all – the behaviour that’s behind things. For the first time in my career I could get involved in and learn from other specialties & non-medical problems.’ ‘I took note of what you said, approached the finance director differently – and we now have the money!’ ‘It showed me I don’t have to be liked!, and that you can’t do things that seem right to everyone… made me ask myself what I stand for as a leader.’ |
Case Study: General Practitioner leadership programme
|
Peter Mumford and his colleague, Breda Flaherty were approached by a PCT wanting to develop a leadership programme accessible and relevant to General Practitioners becoming involved with commissioning and service leadership. The programme ran over a 3 month period, with one day modules. It focused on understand the evolving context of General Practice, their own preferences and strengths in relation to leadership and influence, where best to put their effort given PCT needs and their interests and capabilities. The programme was specifically designed to develop leadership skills that would also be of value to participants and their partners in their General Practice. |
‘I feel the clinical leadership programme has far out-weighed my expectations. I feel a “new person” – clear about my role and direction, who to make connections with.’ ‘I now have a strategy for dealing with a difficult colleague who runs a chaotic service’ ‘I wish I had had access to this support and insight years ago.’ ‘I have really enjoyed and benefited from this development programme. It has been great fun and energising and has given me a great deal of food for thought.’ |
Case Study: Mediation in Accident and Emergency Department
|
We were approached by a Chief Executive faced with a poorly performing and demoralised A&E department. The department was under pressure from other clinical departments and from the Hospital Board. We agreed to interview the main parties involved and then agree jointly a course of action with the department leads, Medical Director and Chief Executive. At the core of the work was the need to re-establish relationships between the consultants and from this help them re-establish departmental leadership and coherent clinical teams in the context of a long term and official grievance between two medical colleagues. |
We worked with the clinical leadership team to re-establish productive professional relationships, enable the clinical leadership team to clarify responsibilities, discuss and agree standards of behaviour and practice more constructive approaches to conflict resolution. |
Case Study: Impact assessment of proposed GP-led ‘Darzi’ Centre
|
A PCT Board had decided on the basis of population, need and experience to place a GP-led ‘Darzi’ primary care centre in a particular market town. Met with strong resistance from existing practices the Board agree to undertake an impact assessment on existing services. We were approached to undertake this assessment. |
We spent time with each of the practices and with other service providers, listening to and testing their concerns. From this we proposed significant modifications to the proposal which would meet the PCT’s rigorous requirements, provide a distinctive and needed service and have the potential to integrate well with and be supported by existing providers. |
Case Study: Service development for a multi-agency service
|
The Strategic Board of a London–wide multi agency body commissioned Peter Mumford and colleague, Breda Flaherty, to develop a 5 year strategy for service development, and recommend priorities. We interviewed key service providers and managers from the agencies involved, reviewed statistics, synthesised relevant policies and in collaboration with the Board produced the report. |
‘I am writing on behalf of the Strategic Board to thank you for all of the work carried out for the Strategic Board. The Board adopted the paper. We will be re-convening our group, and opening up for new membership. We will consider strategic priorities, and also review existing sub-groups to establish and decide if further groups are required’ |